It is NEVER going to be the same!

It sometimes shocks me that newcomers want to not only have the cake, eat it but then they want to hog it for themselves!

It’s no secret that compared to the real estate wasteland out there, Newburyport is looking pretty good right now.       Contractors and developers are practically drooling and want in…badly.          Problem is, the place is loaded with these colonial, way-to-small, buildings that anyone from the ‘masses’ would normally laugh at as a future prospect.

The solution?      Tear the ‘old’, rooms-to-small, midget homes down and put up a bigger house for 21st century appetites.      The usual rational is, “We’ll put up a new house that ‘looks’ old but will be code-compliant and suitable for a ‘modern’ lifestyle.    Sometimes, they’ll throw a carrot-stick out to the local boards and claim they’ll use old elements in the new construction.

And that’s where they trip up badly.

Problem, the word, “code-complaint”.       All the things that make an historic home so attractive are not possible because new construction must follow the newest codes.        It doesn’t make any difference if you replicate a colonial, or a Federalist or a Georgian; they will never be the same.      They will be a Neo-colonial, a neo-Federalist and a ne0-Georgian.       Just built a brand-new Greek Revival?     Sorry, that’s a neo-Greek Revival.    

Because it’s new?      NO!      

Because the proportions and construction techniques that were used in the original designs would violate grossly the new requirements of the Massachusetts Building Code.      And don’t forget the stringent ‘Stretch Code’ in which authentic historic homes are exempt from!

Let’s face it, if Newburyport is replaced by faux historic homes, it will cease to be an historic community.     You can not replace authenticity.        

And that is why a local historic district ordinance is a must for our future.       Without it, we will have a future in which we become a Disney ‘historic town tourist trap’         We might fool some but eventually the word will get out and our fate will be sealed.        

I didn’t move to Newburyport to end up in a ‘has-been’ community.

-P. Preservationist


About P. Preservationist

Dedicated to the Enrichment & Preservation of Newburyport
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to It is NEVER going to be the same!

  1. Port Sanity says:

    PPreservationist’s heart is in the right place … (s)he wants to preserve the historic homes of Newburyport for future generations. It’s an admirable endeavor, and to those hearty homeowners who preserve their historic homes, my hat if off. I respect and admire your efforts.

    That being said, as a resident of Newburyport, I am suspect of the underlying beliefs of PPreservationist that his/her view of the future of Newburyport is the only correct one. and that in order to achieve it, “a local historic district ordinance is a must for our future.” If I were the owner of a home that would become subject to an historic district ordinance (I am not), I would be offended at PPreservationist’s intrusion upon my rights as a homeowner. As a homeowner, I believe that, within limits established for reasons of safety, infrastructure management, and land use management, the home I choose to build or renovate on my property is, with all due respect, none of his/her business. If I choose to incorporate “old elements” in my home, it’s not a “carrot stick,” but a choice, just as it is a choice if I choose to paint my house white, blue, green, or yellow. What else would PPreservationist say I could do in my house?

    I didn’t move to Newburyport to end up in a community where the community makes my choices for me.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s